Written By: Kristin Llewelyn Founder of The Sponsorship Company
Maybe the problem isn't sponsorships. Maybe it's how we think about them.
Few marketing investments seem to generate as much debate in the credit union industry as sponsorships, particularly when professional sports, stadium naming rights, and multimillion-dollar agreements are involved.
Spend a little time in these conversations, and you'll hear some familiar arguments.
Why are we spending millions to put our name on a building? Shouldn't that money go back to members? How many checking accounts does a stadium sponsorship actually open?
These are fair questions. In fact, they're questions credit unions should be asking before making any significant investment. But after 19 years in the credit union industry and 14 years working in sponsorships and partnerships, I've noticed something.
We're often comparing the worst examples of sponsorship marketing to the best examples of traditional marketing. And in doing so, we're overlooking what strategic sponsorships can actually accomplish.
Why Sponsorships Get So Much Scrutiny
Credit unions are member-owned, mission-driven cooperatives. There's an expectation that every dollar invested should ultimately benefit our members.
As there should be.
When a credit union announces a multimillion-dollar naming rights agreement, the investment is highly visible. Everyone sees the name on the building, but very few people see the strategy, negotiated benefits, business opportunities, or measurement framework behind the agreement.
And when all people see is a logo, it's understandable that they question the value.
But what if that agreement also provides access to new markets, intellectual property rights, exclusive content, member benefits, community programming, business relationships, and opportunities to grow deposits, lending, and membership?
That's a very different investment. The difference is strategy, and that's where the conversation should begin.
A Sponsorship Isn't the Campaign
One argument I hear frequently is that credit unions would be better off investing in digital marketing, AI-powered search, social campaigns, or direct member acquisition rather than sponsorships.
But why are we treating these as competing strategies?
Let's say a credit union is expanding into a new market. It needs to build awareness, introduce its products and services, and give prospective members a reason to choose it.
Naturally, that might involve digital advertising, social campaigns, public relations, direct mail, and community outreach.
Now imagine layering in a strategic partnership with a university, professional sports team, or established community organization that already has meaningful relationships with the audiences the credit union wants to reach.
Through negotiated marketing rights, the credit union could integrate its campaigns into partner channels, create relevant content, offer exclusive member benefits, host financial wellness experiences, and connect with prospective members in person.
Suddenly, the sponsorship isn't a separate marketing expense competing with the campaign. It's helping bring that campaign to life across more touchpoints.
A sponsorship isn't the campaign. It's a strategic platform that can make your entire marketing strategy more effective. When done well, sponsorships support advertising, public relations, social media, digital marketing, content development, member engagement, and business development.
That's not an alternative to marketing. That's integrated marketing.
Think Bigger: Sponsorships Are an Enterprise Growth Opportunity
Here's where I believe credit unions are leaving significant value on the table.
We often evaluate sponsorships as a marketing expense when we should be exploring their potential as an enterprise-wide business investment.
Consider how credit unions approach strategic planning.
Leadership establishes priorities around membership growth, deposit acquisition, lending, market expansion, member engagement, and community impact. Departments develop strategies and budgets to support those goals.
Yet sponsorships are often planned, negotiated, and managed almost entirely within marketing, with success measured primarily through impressions, media exposure, and brand awareness.
What if we approached sponsorships differently?
What if, before negotiating an agreement, we asked how the partnership could support the credit union's broader strategic priorities?
Consider a university partnership: From a marketing perspective, it may offer access to an engaged audience, valuable intellectual property, content opportunities, and brand visibility. But look at the opportunities beyond marketing.
Membership growth: Could the partnership introduce the credit union to students, faculty, staff, alumni, and other eligible audiences? Could we create a clear path from engagement to membership?
Deposit growth and business banking: Could we develop a financial relationship with the university, athletic department, affiliated organizations, or businesses within its ecosystem? Are there opportunities to support their banking, treasury, or lending needs?
Workplace banking: Could we create financial wellness programs, employee benefits, and workplace banking opportunities for university employees or other eligible groups?
Consumer lending: Could the partnership support relevant financial education, product campaigns, and lending opportunities for audiences at different life stages?
Member engagement and retention: Could we negotiate exclusive experiences, discounts, and benefits that provide existing members with tangible value and deepen their relationship with the credit union?
Community impact: How can we collaborate with the sponsorship partner, leverage our combined resources, and engage their audience to amplify our efforts and create a greater, more meaningful impact in the communities we serve?
And importantly, could these opportunities support each other?
A financial wellness program might introduce prospective members to the credit union. Those relationships could lead to new accounts or lending opportunities. Member benefits could strengthen engagement and retention. A commercial relationship could create additional deposits and opportunities for collaboration.
Meanwhile, marketing amplifies those programs through the partnership's channels, creating broader awareness and supporting business development.
One partnership can contribute to multiple strategic priorities, creating value that extends well beyond the marketing department.
Of course, these opportunities aren't automatic. The audiences must be relevant and eligible, the benefits must be negotiated, and the credit union needs the operational capacity to deliver. But that's precisely why enterprise-level planning matters.
Instead of marketing purchasing a sponsorship and then looking for ways to use the benefits, what if we brought the right departments to the table before the agreement was signed?
What if retail banking, business development, lending, community engagement, and marketing helped identify opportunities, establish goals, and determine how the investment could support their priorities?
And what if we built the measurement framework around those shared objectives? Now we're evaluating more than media exposure. We're looking at qualified leads, new memberships, deposit relationships, lending opportunities, member engagement, retention, commercial lending and community outcomes. We're also evaluating the full investment, including sponsorship fees, activation, staffing, and supporting marketing, against the value the partnership can reasonably contribute.
Not every outcome will be directly attributable to the sponsorship, and not every partnership should be expected to deliver every benefit. But with clear objectives, accountable owners, and appropriate measurement, we can better understand its contribution.
That's a much more meaningful way to evaluate an investment.
The real opportunity isn't simply getting more marketing assets for our sponsorship dollars. It's creating more enterprise value from the partnerships we choose to invest in.
Community Isn't Just a Marketing Strategy. It's Part of the Credit Union Movement.
Here's another piece of the conversation I think we're overlooking. Credit unions were built on the idea of People Helping People. Showing up for our communities isn't some optional marketing initiative. It's fundamental to who we are.
We talk about supporting local communities, building relationships, investing in financial well-being, and making a difference beyond traditional banking.
So why are we sometimes so quick to dismiss sponsorships, one of the ways credit unions can put those commitments into action?
Think about the community organizations, local festivals, universities, youth sports programs, nonprofits, and cultural events that credit unions support. These partnerships can help organizations deliver programs, create accessible experiences, support local economies, and bring people together. And they give credit unions an opportunity to be part of those communities in meaningful ways.
Not just as a financial institution asking for someone's business, but as an organization genuinely invested in the people and places it serves. There's value in that.
Of course, writing a check doesn't automatically create community impact. Neither does putting a logo on a Little League jersey or a stadium.
But when a credit union actively participates, provides resources, creates member benefits, supports financial education, or helps a community partner expand its impact, that sponsorship becomes something much more meaningful.
For credit unions, community impact shouldn't be separate from business strategy. It should be woven into it
A partnership can support a local organization while also introducing prospective members to the credit union, creating opportunities for financial education, strengthening existing relationships, and supporting long-term growth. In fact, I would argue that this combination of mission and business strategy is exactly where credit unions have an opportunity to differentiate themselves.
We should absolutely hold sponsorships accountable.
But let's make sure we're evaluating the full picture, including the community value we're creating and the relationships we're building.
After all, what does People Helping People look like if we're not actively showing up for people?
When Technology Makes Comparison Easier, Human Connection Becomes a Differentiator
Here's another reason I believe sponsorships deserve a bigger conversation, especially right now. The way consumers discover and evaluate financial institutions is changing.
People can ask ChatGPT or another AI assistant which credit union has the best auto loan rates, lowest fees, or most competitive financial products. Within seconds, they can receive recommendations, comparisons, and information to help narrow their choices.
And they're increasingly doing just that.
According to Deloitte's 2026 banking consumer research, 58% of surveyed generative AI users had used these tools to research banking products.
That creates an interesting challenge for credit unions.
When consumers can compare financial institutions in seconds, how do we give them a reason to choose us beyond the rate sheet?
Competitive products, pricing, and convenience will always matter. And credit unions need to ensure they're discoverable through emerging technology.
But our industry has always claimed to offer something more. People helping people, community, relationships, trust. How do we demonstrate those qualities to someone who has never experienced our credit union?
That's where I believe sponsorships have an opportunity to shine.
Think about the last time you attended a community festival, sporting event, or local celebration. These are places where people come together around something they genuinely enjoy or care about.
Now imagine a credit union showing up in a way that adds value to that experience.
Maybe it's offering an exclusive benefit to members, helping a family understand their financial options, supporting a community initiative, or simply having a meaningful conversation with someone who has never considered joining a credit union.
These interactions give people an opportunity to experience the brand, not just read about it.
And research suggests people continue to value those experiences.
Eventbrite's 2026 Social Study found that 74% of surveyed Gen Z respondents believe in-person experiences are more important than digital ones, while 89% of surveyed young adults want events that connect them to their communities.
Separately, research from The Freeman Company and The Harris Poll found that 77% of consumers who attended a brand event said the experience positively shifted their belief in that brand.
Neither study proves that sponsorships automatically create trust or generate new members. But they reinforce the potential value of meaningful, in-person brand experiences.
And that's something credit unions should pay attention to.
A chatbot can help someone compare financial products. A credit union can create an experience that helps someone understand the people, purpose, and community behind those products.
One helps consumers evaluate their options. The other gives them a reason to build a relationship. The two aren't mutually exclusive.
The goal isn't to compete with technology. It's to recognize that as technology makes comparing financial institutions easier, the experiences and relationships that distinguish us may become even more valuable.
Sponsorships give us an opportunity to build those relationships where people already are, in the communities we're here to serve.
But only if we do more than put our logo on the banner.
Awareness Isn't the Enemy. But It Can't Be the Entire Strategy.
Another common criticism is that sponsorships are simply expensive awareness plays.
And sometimes, they are. But awareness has value. People generally need to know who you are before they'll consider doing business with you.
The challenge is that awareness alone doesn't necessarily translate into results. Recognizing a credit union's name on a stadium doesn't mean someone will open an account tomorrow. But awareness can be the beginning of a relationship, not the end of one. The real opportunity lies in connecting that awareness to meaningful experiences, ongoing engagement, consideration, and ultimately business growth. The goal should be to create a path from awareness to action.
What are we doing with the audience we're reaching? How are we engaging them? What reason are we giving them to consider our credit union? And how are we nurturing that relationship beyond the initial interaction?
A sponsorship should never be expected to magically generate business simply because the agreement was signed.
Buying sponsorship rights is not the same thing as building a sponsorship strategy.
The value comes from how those rights are leveraged.
Are We Holding Sponsorships to a Different Standard?
Here's something else I find interesting.
Credit unions will sometimes scrutinize a sports sponsorship for not producing immediate membership growth while investing significant dollars in television, radio, billboards, or other brand advertising without expecting that same direct return.
Why?
A billboard doesn't necessarily open checking accounts. A television commercial doesn't automatically generate loan applications.
Yet we recognize that these investments can play an important role in building familiarity, trust, and consideration over time.
Why do we sometimes demand immediate ROI from sponsorships while giving traditional brand advertising more room to demonstrate its long-term value?
I'm not suggesting sponsorships deserve less accountability. I'm suggesting every marketing investment deserves consistent accountability. If awareness is the objective, measure awareness. If membership acquisition is the objective, build a strategy that supports acquisition and track the results. And if a sponsorship is designed to support awareness, acquisition, engagement, and community impact, evaluate those outcomes accordingly.
The same principle applies across the sponsorship portfolio. A community festival, university partnership, nonprofit initiative, and professional sports agreement may have very different objectives.
They shouldn't automatically be measured using identical KPIs. That doesn't mean we ignore the financial investment. Quite the opposite.
At the enterprise level, we should understand the total cost of the partnership, including rights fees, activation, staffing, and supporting marketing. We should also evaluate its contribution to business growth, member relationships, brand strength, and community outcomes over time.
Not every benefit can be translated into immediate revenue, and not every business result can be attributed entirely to a sponsorship. But we can establish credible measures, track performance, and make more informed decisions about where to invest.
The goal isn't to manufacture ROI. It's to understand the full value of the investment and hold it accountable to the outcomes it was designed to deliver.
Here's Where I Agree With the Critics
Not every sponsorship is worth the money.
Some credit unions are spending significant dollars without a clearly defined strategy, sufficient activation resources, or meaningful performance measurement.
Some sponsorships are selected because of personal relationships or preferences rather than organizational priorities. And sometimes, organizations negotiate an agreement, sign the contract, and assume the marketing value will happen on its own.
It won't. Sponsorships require strategy, investment, collaboration, and ongoing management. They should align with the credit union's mission, audience, growth priorities, and capacity to execute. And when those things aren't present, we should absolutely question the investment.
I'm not advocating for credit unions to spend more money on sponsorships. I'm advocating for credit unions to think bigger about the value their sponsorships can deliver.
Sometimes that means renegotiating an agreement. Sometimes it means rethinking the activation strategy, identifying overlooked assets, or involving additional departments. And sometimes it means walking away. That's what responsible sponsorship management looks like.
Maybe It's Time to Change the Conversation
I don't believe credit unions should invest millions in sponsorships simply because other financial institutions are doing it. I also don't believe we should dismiss sponsorships because the most visible asset happens to be a logo on a stadium. Both perspectives overlook the bigger opportunity.
Sponsorships can help credit unions reach new audiences, build relationships, create meaningful experiences, strengthen communities, and support enterprise growth.
But only when they're structured and activated with intention.
Instead of asking, "Why would a credit union spend that much money on a sponsorship?"
Maybe we should be asking:
What are we trying to accomplish? How does this partnership support our broader business strategy? What opportunities are we creating for our members and communities? And how will we know whether it's working?
Those are much more productive questions.
Because sponsorships aren't inherently good or bad investments.
The real question is whether we're treating them as strategic business opportunities or simply buying visibility and hoping for results.
And in an industry built on relationships, community, and people helping people, I think that's a conversation worth having.
Impact Over Impressions.
Are you getting the most out of your sponsorship investments?
Whether you're evaluating a new opportunity, looking to maximize an existing partnership, or rethinking your sponsorship strategy, I'd love to help you uncover what's possible.
At The Sponsorship Company, I help credit unions and mission-driven brands turn sponsorships into meaningful business results, stronger relationships, and lasting community impact.
Let's connect and explore the opportunities. kristin@thesponsorshipcompany.org

